History is made as Bo Jackson emerged as Auburn Player of All Time over Pat Sullivan, a scrutiny votes by fans

It’s no surprise that a Heisman Trophy winner was selected as the best Auburn football player of the modern era in our 16-man bracket.

But the one who was selected is a bit of a stunner. No. 3 seed Pat Sullivan emerged as the champion after four rounds of voting, knocking off No. 1 seed Bo Jackson in a battle of Heisman winners and all-time Tigers legends. Sullivan, the 1971 Heisman winner, won the vote handily, 56% to 44% for Jackson, who took home the Heisman in 1985.

Sullivan was Auburn’s first Heisman winner, and the first from a school in the state of Alabama. More than 50 years after his college career ended, he still holds the Tigers’ all-time record with 53 passing touchdowns, despite having played only three season of varsity football (freshmen were not eligible to play on the varsity until 1972).

AL.com has conducted a number of similar polls over the years, and Jackson — one of the greatest athletes in American sports history — nearly always wins. He dominated the first three rounds of this competition, so his winning the overall title seemed to be a fait accompli.

But it was Sullivan, and not Jackson, who emerged victorious. It’s proof that sports can still surprise you from time to time.

​In a landmark moment for Auburn University, fans recently voted Bo Jackson as the greatest Auburn player of all time, surpassing legendary figures like Pat Sullivan. This decision has sparked discussions about the criteria used to define “greatness” in collegiate athletics and has highlighted the enduring legacies of both Jackson and Sullivan.​

Pat Sullivan: A Legacy of Excellence

Pat Sullivan’s tenure at Auburn (1969–1971) set high standards for excellence. As a three-sport star at John Carroll Catholic High School in Birmingham, Alabama, Sullivan’s impact at Auburn was profound. He led the Tigers to a 9-1 regular-season record in 1971, culminating in Auburn’s first Heisman Trophy. His career totals include 6,284 passing yards and 53 touchdown passes, records that still stand. Beyond statistics, Sullivan’s leadership and sportsmanship left an indelible mark on Auburn’s football history. ​

Bo Jackson: An Icon of Dual-Sport Dominance

Bo Jackson’s Auburn career (1982–1985) is legendary, particularly for his exceptional performances in both football and baseball. In football, Jackson’s achievements are remarkable:​

• 1983 Season: Rushed for 1,213 yards on 158 carries, averaging 7.7 yards per carry.​

• 1985 Season: Rushed for 1,786 yards, earning the Heisman Trophy in a closely contested vote. ​

In baseball, Jackson’s athleticism was equally impressive, playing for Auburn’s team and later achieving MLB success. His unique ability to excel in two major sports has cemented his status as a cultural icon.​

Evaluating “Greatness”: Criteria and Perspectives

The debate over who holds the title of Auburn’s greatest player underscores the subjective nature of evaluating athletic greatness. Key factors often considered include:​

• Individual Statistics: Quantifiable achievements like yards gained, touchdowns scored, and batting averages.​

• Team Success: Contributions to team victories, championships, and overall program prestige.​

• Impact and Influence: The player’s influence on the sport, university, and community, including leadership qualities and off-field contributions.​

Both Sullivan and Jackson excelled across these dimensions, making direct comparisons challenging. Sullivan’s era predated the modern passing game, highlighting his achievements within the context of his time. Jackson’s dual-sport success occurred in a more contemporary athletic landscape, adding complexity to evaluations.​

Fan Voting: Popularity vs. Legacy

The fan vote that elevated Jackson above Sullivan reflects broader societal trends where contemporary figures often receive heightened recognition. While fan opinions are valuable, they may prioritize recent achievements and media presence over historical impact. This phenomenon raises questions about the balance between popular sentiment and historical significance in determining “greatness.”​

Celebrating Auburn’s Rich Athletic Heritage

Both Pat Sullivan and Bo Jackson have left lasting legacies at Auburn University. Sullivan’s leadership and record-setting performances laid a foundation for future success, while Jackson’s exceptional athleticism brought national attention to Auburn’s programs. Rather than viewing their achievements in competition, it is more fitting to celebrate the diverse ways each contributed to Auburn’s storied athletic history.