Dodgers Aim to Set Historic Record with Most MLB All-Star Game Starters as Final Fan Voting Window Opens for 48 Hours
The Los Angeles Dodgers are not only gunning for another World Series title in 2025—they’re chasing history on the All-Star stage as well. With the MLB All-Star Game approaching and Phase 2 of fan voting opening for a crucial 48-hour window, the Dodgers find themselves in position to potentially rewrite the record books by sending an unprecedented number of starters to the Midsummer Classic.
Led by a roster teeming with elite talent, the Dodgers are pushing toward a feat that would reflect their dominance both on the field and in the hearts of fans. With multiple players leading at their respective positions after Phase 1, the next two days of voting will determine whether Los Angeles can place more starters in the All-Star Game than any team in Major League Baseball history.
The current record for most All-Star starters from a single team in a non-exhibition format stands at five, a mark most recently hit by the 2022 Toronto Blue Jays and the 1976 Cincinnati Reds, the latter of whom sent seven players in the now-defunct fan voting format of that era. The Dodgers, bolstered by a global fanbase and a stacked lineup, could break or match that historic high depending on the final results of the Phase 2 voting.
Stars like Mookie Betts, Shohei Ohtani, Freddie Freeman, Will Smith, and Teoscar Hernández are all in contention for starting nods. Each brings not only elite statistics but also strong fan appeal—something that matters deeply in the voting process. Betts and Ohtani, in particular, are not just MLB superstars but cultural icons with international fanbases, giving the Dodgers a substantial edge in fan-driven selections.
Mookie Betts, now in his fifth season with the Dodgers, continues to show why he’s a perennial MVP candidate. With dazzling defensive versatility—having played right field, shortstop, and second base this year—and a bat that consistently produces, Betts has solidified himself as a top vote-getter in the National League. His popularity and impact on both coasts (dating back to his Boston Red Sox days) have kept him front and center in the All-Star voting.
Then there’s Shohei Ohtani, the most electrifying player in modern baseball. Although Tommy John surgery has limited him to designated hitter duties this season, Ohtani has not missed a beat at the plate. He leads the Dodgers—and perhaps the National League—in OPS, home runs, and slugging percentage. A two-way phenom whose unique talent transcends traditional roles, Ohtani is arguably the most marketable player in the world, and fans have responded in droves.
Both Betts and Ohtani are near-locks to start, barring a dramatic swing in voting. Their presence alone is enough to make headlines, but for the Dodgers, it’s just the beginning.
Freddie Freeman continues to be the heartbeat of the Dodgers’ lineup. After signing with Los Angeles in 2022, Freeman has been nothing short of spectacular—routinely hitting over .300, driving in runs, and playing Gold Glove-caliber defense at first base. His steadiness at the plate and leadership in the clubhouse make him a fan favorite and a strong candidate to join Betts and Ohtani as a starter.
Freeman is currently battling stiff competition from names like Bryce Harper (who’s playing first base for the Phillies) and Pete Alonso. Yet his combination of consistency, popularity, and clutch hitting in prime-time games could give him the edge in these final 48 hours.
Will Smith, often dubbed the most underrated catcher in baseball, has a legitimate shot at earning his first career All-Star Game start. With a potent bat, improved defense, and a vital role as the personal catcher to both Ohtani and the Dodgers’ other aces, Smith has earned widespread respect around the league.
Though competition is fierce—J.T. Realmuto and William Contreras remain fan favorites—Smith’s offensive production cannot be ignored. With a batting average hovering near .290 and a knack for extra-base hits, he’s making a strong case that this year’s All-Star Game should finally showcase his talent on the national stage.
Teoscar Hernández has been one of the pleasant surprises for Los Angeles this season. Acquired during the offseason, Hernández has brought a much-needed right-handed power bat to the lineup, and his clutch hitting has won over fans quickly. His highlight-reel homers and timely run production have made him a force in the outfield alongside Betts.
Though he’s not a household name to the casual fan, Hernández’s numbers speak volumes. His All-Star candidacy has gained serious traction in recent weeks, and with fan momentum building, he may sneak into the starting lineup.
While fan voting is limited to position players, the Dodgers’ pitching staff also deserves attention. Tyler Glasnow and Yoshinobu Yamamoto have anchored the rotation with dominance. Glasnow leads the team in strikeouts and has looked like a Cy Young candidate, while Yamamoto has proven his worth as a prized international signing. Although fans can’t vote them in, their performance likely ensures their inclusion when MLB announces full rosters.
Additionally, the bullpen has been revitalized by arms like Evan Phillips and Brusdar Graterol. Their contributions help underscore just how balanced this Dodgers squad really is, top to bottom.
MLB’s All-Star voting is divided into two phases. In Phase 1, fans vote for all eligible players, narrowing down each position to two finalists per league (three for outfield spots). Now in Phase 2, fans have 48 hours to choose from those finalists—essentially a head-to-head race.
This year’s Phase 2 voting began Monday at noon ET and will end Wednesday at noon ET. The winners will be revealed on ESPN on Wednesday night. Fan votes from Phase 1 do not carry over, meaning players must re-secure their leads with a new wave of support.
That makes this short window crucial for Dodgers players. While the team already had an impressive showing in Phase 1, the race tightens in Phase 2, and organized fan campaigns from rival teams—like the Braves, Phillies, and Cubs—could impact the final numbers.
The Dodgers have embraced the digital age in their All-Star campaign. Social media platforms like Twitter, Instagram, and TikTok have been flooded with highlight reels, interactive graphics, and direct calls to action urging fans to vote. Players themselves have joined in, with Betts and Freeman posting voting reminders, and Ohtani reposting support from fans across Japan.
Team broadcasters, radio hosts, and beat writers have also pitched in, crafting narratives around each player’s All-Star case. Even Dodgers manager Dave Roberts has publicly encouraged fans to vote, noting the importance of celebrating player excellence.
This All-Star push is about more than just individual accolades—it’s a reflection of the Dodgers’ status as baseball’s current superpower. With the best record in the National League and one of the deepest rosters in the game, it’s only fitting that the team sends a record-breaking contingent to the Midsummer Classic.
If the Dodgers can place six or even seven starters, they’ll not only make history but further solidify the narrative that 2025 could be another championship year. The All-Star Game is meant to showcase the best talent in the game—and right now, much of that talent wears Dodger blue.
The 2025 MLB All-Star Game will be held at Globe Life Field in Arlington, Texas, home of the Texas Rangers. While the venue is neutral, it’s expected that Dodgers fans will travel in droves, and with so many Dodgers potentially in the lineup, it may feel like an L.A. showcase.
The event will serve as more than just a midseason celebration. It’s a stage for MVP-level performances, a setting for emerging stars to shine, and in the Dodgers’ case, a possible coronation of the most dominant team in the modern era.
With the voting clock ticking, the baseball world is watching closely. The Dodgers’ All-Star destiny—and their place in history—hangs in the balance of the next 48 hours.
