Making the Case for Each Finalist to Be Crowned the Greatest Ohio State Football Player in History
Ohio State football has produced a pantheon of legends, each leaving an indelible mark on one of college football’s most storied programs. When debating the greatest Buckeye in history, the task is monumental—how do you compare players across eras, positions, and the evolving landscape of the sport? The answer lies in looking closely at the finalists whose careers embody excellence, leadership, and impact, not only on the field but also in the fabric of Ohio State football tradition. To crown the “Greatest Buckeye,” we must consider their accomplishments, influence, versatility, and how their legacies transcend the game itself.
Among the finalists, a few names consistently surface, each representing a different aspect of greatness. From record-setting quarterbacks to game-changing defensive stalwarts, from two-way players to charismatic leaders, these Buckeyes helped shape Ohio State football’s identity and legacy. Their stories span decades, yet all share the common thread of excellence.
Let’s begin with Archie Griffin, the only two-time Heisman Trophy winner in college football history. Griffin’s name is synonymous with Buckeye football greatness, and for good reason. Playing from 1972 to 1975, Griffin exemplified consistency, durability, and elite production in an era where defenses dominated. His style of running was a blend of power, vision, and determination. Griffin rushed for over 5,500 yards and scored 26 touchdowns in his career, becoming a workhorse for Woody Hayes’ powerhouse teams. Beyond stats, Griffin’s back-to-back Heisman wins in 1974 and 1975 place him in a category all his own. It wasn’t just individual accolades; his leadership helped Ohio State win multiple Big Ten titles and contend nationally. Griffin’s impact extended beyond his playing days as he became a symbol of Buckeye pride and excellence. For many, he is the standard by which all others are measured.
However, the argument for greatest Buckeye doesn’t rest solely on offense. Consider Jack Tatum, a hard-hitting defensive back whose nickname “The Assassin” captured the fear he instilled in opponents. Tatum’s Ohio State career spanned the late 1960s, where his ferocity and instincts redefined defensive back play. He was a consensus All-American and known for his physicality, ball-hawking ability, and unmatched toughness. Tatum’s presence helped Ohio State dominate defensively during a golden era and contributed to the 1968 national championship. His influence on the game transcended college, paving the way for a legendary NFL career. For those valuing defensive dominance and an unyielding competitive spirit, Tatum represents a pillar of Buckeye greatness.
On the quarterback side, Troy Smith’s case for the greatest Buckeye cannot be overlooked. Smith’s 2006 Heisman Trophy campaign was one of the most electrifying in Ohio State history. Known for his poise, accuracy, and leadership, Smith guided the Buckeyes to an undefeated regular season and a spot in the BCS National Championship game. His dual-threat capability expanded Ohio State’s offensive playbook, and his ability to perform under pressure endeared him to fans and teammates alike. Smith’s accomplishments include a school-record completion percentage and clutch performances in critical moments. His rise in a more modern era, with increased media exposure and competition, adds weight to his candidacy. For those who admire quarterback excellence in the contemporary game, Troy Smith is a definitive choice.
Similarly, Eddie George’s name shines brightly in the pantheon of Buckeye greats. George was a workhorse running back in the mid-1990s, a Heisman Trophy winner in 1995 who epitomized hard work and grit. His powerful running style, combined with impressive speed and vision, helped Ohio State reach new heights. George rushed for over 3,500 yards and 37 touchdowns in his collegiate career, leading the Buckeyes to a Rose Bowl victory in his senior year. Beyond individual stats, his ability to carry the offense and inspire teammates made him a fan favorite and a symbol of Ohio State toughness. George’s transition to the NFL further solidified his legacy, making him an enduring figure in Buckeye lore.
No conversation about the greatest Buckeye would be complete without mentioning Cris Carter. Though more widely known for his Hall of Fame NFL career, Carter’s time at Ohio State was foundational. Playing in the late 1980s, Carter showcased elite route-running, reliable hands, and game-changing playmaking ability. He caught over 100 passes for more than 1,500 yards, setting the stage for Ohio State’s evolving passing offense. Carter’s influence on the Buckeyes’ aerial attack helped modernize the program’s offensive identity. His perseverance and professionalism serve as an example for Buckeyes across generations, proving greatness isn’t confined to college achievements alone.
On the defensive line, A.J. Hawk stands out as a candidate for the greatest Buckeye. Hawk’s tenure from 2002 to 2005 was marked by relentless pursuit, leadership, and versatility. As a three-time All-American and 2005 Butkus Award winner, Hawk anchored a dominant defense and helped lead Ohio State to a national championship game appearance. His ability to read offenses, make tackles for loss, and inspire teammates made him a defensive leader of the modern era. Hawk’s consistency and football IQ reflect the qualities Ohio State fans cherish in their players: toughness, intelligence, and unwavering effort.
While the finalists represent different eras and positions, what unites them is their embodiment of Ohio State’s core values: leadership, excellence, and a relentless pursuit of victory. Whether a player dominated statistically or served as an emotional leader, their contributions shaped Ohio State’s identity and left a lasting impression on the program.
Another layer in the debate involves comparing across eras—how does one fairly judge a player from the 1960s against one from the 2000s? The sport has evolved dramatically, with changes in training, rules, season length, and competition level. Yet, greatness transcends such variables. It is measured by dominance relative to peers, impact on team success, and the legacy left behind. Archie Griffin’s two Heisman trophies during a rugged run-first era speak volumes about his dominance, just as Troy Smith’s success in a quarterback-centric, media-intense environment highlights his adaptability and skill.
The positional diversity among finalists also reflects Ohio State’s comprehensive excellence. From running backs like Griffin and George to quarterbacks like Smith, from defensive stalwarts like Tatum and Hawk to receivers like Carter, each position carries unique challenges and responsibilities. The greatest Buckeye is not just the best at a single role but the one whose presence elevated the entire team’s performance and legacy.
Leadership plays a critical role in this discussion. Many of these finalists were not only stars on the field but also captains and role models in the locker room. Their ability to inspire teammates through adversity and success alike is part of their greatness. Ohio State’s rich tradition is built on players who not only excel individually but also foster team unity and resilience.
Moreover, cultural impact cannot be overlooked. Archie Griffin, for instance, became a symbol of Ohio State’s values and pride for generations beyond his playing days. His name is synonymous with Buckeye excellence, and his legacy continues to inspire young athletes. Similarly, players like Cris Carter and Eddie George have remained influential voices for the program, mentoring and supporting new generations of Buckeyes.
Ultimately, the question of the greatest Ohio State football player is subjective, influenced by personal biases, generational loyalty, and criteria weighting. But this debate itself celebrates the remarkable history of Buckeye football and the extraordinary individuals who have worn the scarlet and gray.
Each finalist makes a compelling case: Archie Griffin’s unmatched collegiate accolades and steady leadership; Jack Tatum’s fearsome defense and impact on championships; Troy Smith’s Heisman-winning leadership in a modern era; Eddie George’s relentless power running and clutch performances; Cris Carter’s game-changing receiving skills and professional success; and A.J. Hawk’s defensive mastery and cerebral play. They represent the best of Ohio State football in different ways, and their legacies form a rich tapestry of greatness.
For Ohio State fans, these debates keep the spirit of the program alive, bridging generations and reminding everyone why Ohio State football remains one of college football’s crown jewels. The “Greatest Buckeye” title is more than a name—it’s a celebration of excellence, leadership, and a legacy that inspires every player stepping onto the field at Ohio Stadium.
In the end, whether one picks Archie Griffin for his historic Heisman achievements, Troy Smith for his clutch modern-era leadership, Jack Tatum for defensive intimidation, Eddie George for grinding excellence, Cris Carter for receiving prowess, or A.J. Hawk for defensive intellect, the true greatest Buckeye is the spirit that these legends collectively embody—a relentless pursuit of greatness that defines Ohio State football.
