Nicole May Returns Home as Associate Head Coach in Monumental Move That Signals New Era for Oklahoma Softball Dynasty

In a move that has sent shockwaves through the college softball world, Nicole May is officially returning to Oklahoma—this time, not as a player, but as the program’s Associate Head Coach. For Sooner Nation, it marks not just a reunion but a powerful statement about the future of the sport’s most dominant dynasty.

Nicole May, known for her fiery competitiveness, relentless work ethic, and championship pedigree, comes home after building her coaching reputation elsewhere. Her appointment signals Oklahoma’s commitment to both tradition and evolution as the program enters a new era following historic success under head coach Patty Gasso.

For longtime Oklahoma fans, May’s return evokes memories of her dominant performances in the circle, where she played a pivotal role in securing national championships and cementing Oklahoma’s place atop the softball world. Her arrival on the coaching staff now represents more than nostalgia—it represents continuity, leadership, and the passing of the torch to someone who understands, better than most, what it takes to wear the crimson and cream with pride.

The hire is monumental in many ways, but perhaps most importantly, it underscores Oklahoma’s strategy to ensure its dynasty not only survives but thrives in an increasingly competitive collegiate softball landscape. With new powerhouse programs emerging and the transfer portal altering recruiting battles, keeping Oklahoma at the pinnacle demands innovative coaching, strong recruiting pipelines, and a culture steeped in championship expectations.

Nicole May checks every box.

A California native, May first made her mark as one of the nation’s most sought-after high school pitchers before choosing Oklahoma—a decision that reshaped both her career and the program’s trajectory. During her time in Norman, she evolved from a promising freshman into one of the cornerstones of the Sooners’ dominance. Her performances in high-stakes moments, particularly during Women’s College World Series appearances, endeared her to fans and earned respect across the sport.

May’s career numbers at Oklahoma speak for themselves: multiple All-Big 12 selections, key postseason wins, and a reputation for being nearly untouchable when it mattered most. But beyond the stats, it was her intensity, preparation, and leadership that set her apart. Those same qualities are now what she brings to the dugout, where she will work closely with Coach Gasso to develop pitching talent and elevate the Sooners’ already elite roster.

The news of her appointment comes at a crucial juncture for Oklahoma. After capturing four consecutive national titles and establishing one of the most formidable runs in college sports history, the Sooners face both immense expectations and new challenges. Their dominance has made them the team every opponent circles on the schedule, and sustaining that excellence requires constant adaptation.

Enter Nicole May.

Her intimate knowledge of Oklahoma’s culture, coupled with her experience in coaching and player development, positions her perfectly to impact the program from day one. Moreover, her unique ability to connect with players, having walked in their cleats not long ago, provides a relatability that few coaches can offer.

Her rise through the coaching ranks was as impressive as her playing career. Following her graduation, May honed her craft as a pitching coach and assistant at other collegiate programs, where she quickly earned a reputation for her technical expertise and motivational style. Former players have praised her ability to break down mechanics, while simultaneously fostering confidence and mental toughness—the very qualities that defined her own playing career.

The reaction from the Oklahoma softball community has been overwhelmingly positive. Former teammates, current players, and alumni have taken to social media to express their excitement. Many view May’s return as a full-circle moment, one that reaffirms Oklahoma’s identity as a family-oriented program where champions return to invest in the next generation.

Head coach Patty Gasso, widely regarded as one of the greatest leaders in softball history, was deliberate in her search for an associate head coach capable of upholding the Sooners’ standard of excellence. In Nicole May, Gasso not only adds a tactician and mentor but someone who understands, down to her core, what it means to compete for Oklahoma.

In a statement released following the announcement, Gasso expressed her excitement, stating, “Nicole embodies everything this program stands for—hard work, grit, and a relentless pursuit of excellence. She understands the pressure, the tradition, and the expectations because she’s lived it. Her return is not just special for our team, but for the entire Sooner family.”

For May, the opportunity is as personal as it is professional. Returning to Norman brings back memories of championship celebrations, grueling practices, and the support of a fanbase that lives and breathes softball. Yet, her mindset remains focused on the task ahead: building on Oklahoma’s legacy and preparing players to meet the ever-growing demands of the sport.

“This place shaped me, and it’s an honor to be back in a role where I can help shape the next generation of Sooners,” May shared during her introductory press conference. “The standard here is simple—championships, development, and representing the university with pride. I’m ready to get to work.”

Her appointment also sends a strong message to recruits nationwide. As programs like UCLA, Florida State, and Texas invest heavily in their softball futures, Oklahoma’s decision to bring back one of its own, with a proven track record both on the field and on the recruiting trail, is strategic. May’s California roots and national profile broaden Oklahoma’s reach in securing top-tier talent.

Oklahoma softball has long been known for innovation, particularly in pitching. With May at the helm of the pitching staff, expect a continued emphasis on blending power, precision, and mental resilience. Her own career was defined by overcoming adversity, learning from setbacks, and peaking when it mattered most—lessons she’s eager to instill in the Sooners’ current and future aces.

The timing of her return could not be more pivotal. With several veteran players graduating and a new wave of talent entering the program, May’s leadership will be instrumental in maintaining team chemistry and ensuring a smooth transition. The Sooners may have dominated in recent years, but sustaining greatness is arguably a tougher challenge than building it—and May is ready for the moment.

Her hiring also represents an evolution in Gasso’s coaching tree, as former players increasingly step into significant coaching roles, further embedding the program’s philosophy and competitive edge across the sport. It’s a testament to Oklahoma’s culture of excellence and player development that athletes like May are prepared to lead at the highest level so soon after their playing careers conclude.

Looking ahead, expectations remain sky-high. Oklahoma fans demand nothing less than championship contention year after year, and with May’s return, those aspirations feel well within reach. Her presence brings a fresh energy, deep institutional knowledge, and a championship pedigree unmatched in the college softball landscape.

As the new season approaches, all eyes will be on Norman. The Sooners have reloaded, their coaching staff has never been stronger, and with Nicole May back where it all began, the program appears poised to write the next chapter of its historic dynasty.

For Nicole May, this homecoming isn’t just about nostalgia—it’s about legacy, leadership, and keeping Oklahoma softball exactly where it belongs: on top of the softball world.