Ohio State University has long been a breeding ground for NFL talent, consistently producing players who make significant impacts at the professional level. However, recent developments suggest that some of the Buckeyes’ star athletes are experiencing unexpected declines in their NFL Draft stock. This phenomenon is particularly intriguing, given the university’s reputation for excellence and the high expectations placed on its players.
C.J. Stroud: From Heisman Finalist to Draft Uncertainty
C.J. Stroud’s journey from a two-time Heisman finalist to a quarterback facing draft uncertainties is nothing short of remarkable. Despite his impressive collegiate performance, Stroud’s draft stock has been adversely affected by a combination of factors. Notably, a low score on the S2 Test—a cognitive assessment measuring decision-making speed and accuracy—raised concerns among NFL executives. One executive remarked that Stroud’s score of 18% was alarmingly low, suggesting potential challenges at the professional level.
Compounding these concerns is the historical underperformance of Ohio State quarterbacks in the NFL. Stroud has been unfairly linked to this trend, with critics questioning his potential based on past Buckeyes’ shortcomings. Deion Sanders addressed this bias, emphasizing that each player should be evaluated on their individual merits rather than the perceived failures of predecessors.
Josh Simmons: Injury Clouds First-Round Prospects
Offensive tackle Josh Simmons was once viewed as a top-tier prospect for the 2025 NFL Draft. His transition from San Diego State to Ohio State was seamless; he delivered standout performances without conceding a single sack. However, a season-ending knee injury against Oregon in October 2024 cast a shadow over his draft prospects. Simmons’ agent remains optimistic, stating that Simmons will be fully cleared for practice by the start of NFL training camp and is projected to be a high first-round pick.
Donovan Jackson: Versatility Boosts Draft Stock
In contrast to Simmons, Donovan Jackson’s adaptability has enhanced his draft prospects. Initially recognized as a top guard, Jackson’s move to tackle due to Simmons’ injury showcased his versatility. His pivotal role in securing Ohio State’s national championship further elevated his status, positioning him as a potential first-round pick.
Jack Sawyer and Sonny Styles: Decisions to Return Raise Eyebrows
Defensive standouts Jack Sawyer and Sonny Styles made the surprising decision to return to Ohio State for the 2025 season, foregoing potential NFL opportunities. Sawyer’s choice was driven by a desire to achieve goals unfulfilled during his previous tenure, including defeating Michigan and securing a national championship. Styles felt he had more to prove and wasn’t ready to transition to the professional realm.
A Pattern of Pre-Draft Stock Fluctuations
The experiences of Stroud, Simmons, Jackson, Sawyer, and Styles are not isolated incidents. Historically, Ohio State players have faced fluctuating draft stocks influenced by factors such as injuries, position changes, and pre-draft evaluations. For instance, in the previous draft cycle, wide receiver Garrett Wilson’s stock was affected by rumors about his interview performance, leading to his selection after Drake London.
The Influence of Pre-Draft Narratives
The narratives constructed around players during the pre-draft process can significantly impact their perceived value. Positive stories can propel a player’s stock, while negative ones can cause it to plummet. The cases of Stroud and Wilson illustrate how external perceptions and unverified rumors can shape a player’s draft trajectory, regardless of their on-field performance.
