Oklahoma State Cowboys beat writer McClain Baxley provides in-depth answers on 2025 roster outlook, Big 12 competition, and season expectations

Oklahoma State Cowboys beat writer McClain Baxley provides in-depth answers on 2025 roster outlook, Big 12 competition, and season expectations

Oklahoma State football fans are already looking ahead to the 2025 season, eager to see whether the Cowboys can bounce back from an inconsistent campaign. Beat writer McClain Baxley, who covers the team closely, recently fielded a wide range of questions from fans, offering detailed insights into the roster, positional battles, and the broader Big 12 landscape. His perspective paints a picture of a program in transition — still capable of competing, but facing legitimate challenges that will require discipline, development, and leadership to overcome.

One of the first topics Baxley addressed was the quarterback situation. With the position being such a pivotal factor in the Cowboys’ success, fans wanted to know if there’s a clear starter heading into fall camp. Baxley noted that while there are leading candidates, competition remains open, and coaches will use preseason practices to evaluate consistency, decision-making, and leadership qualities. He emphasized that whoever wins the job will need to quickly establish chemistry with the receiving corps and command the offense with confidence.

The offensive line was another point of discussion, as its struggles in 2024 were a major factor in stalled drives and inconsistent scoring. Baxley explained that offseason conditioning and scheme adjustments have been priorities, with new additions and returning players expected to compete for starting spots. He highlighted that improved line play will not only help protect the quarterback but also open up running lanes for a backfield that has the potential to be one of the offense’s most reliable strengths.

Defensively, fans asked about the unit’s ability to slow down the Big 12’s explosive offenses. Baxley acknowledged that the Cowboys’ defensive front looks promising, with several players capable of generating a consistent pass rush. However, he pointed out that the secondary is still a work in progress, and depth could become a concern if injuries arise. He stressed that in a conference where passing attacks can take over games, discipline and communication in the defensive backfield will be crucial.

Special teams questions also came up, particularly regarding field goal consistency and punt coverage. Baxley expressed optimism in the kicking game, noting that reliable special teams play could be an asset in close matchups. He added that hidden yardage from punts and kick returns can quietly shape outcomes, especially in a league where margins are often razor-thin.

The conversation then shifted to the Big 12 as a whole. Fans wanted Baxley’s take on where Oklahoma State fits in the conference hierarchy. He explained that while the Cowboys have enough talent to finish in the upper half, breaking into true championship contention will require a near-perfect blend of health, execution, and composure in high-pressure moments. He noted that with expansion bringing more competitive balance and fewer clear-cut favorites, a team like Oklahoma State could play spoiler, even if they aren’t widely projected to win the league.

Baxley also addressed the team’s schedule, highlighting pivotal swing games that could determine whether the Cowboys exceed or fall short of expectations. He pointed to early-season matchups as tone-setters, where strong performances could build momentum and belief in the locker room. Conversely, slow starts could put the Cowboys in a position where they are constantly playing catch-up in the standings.

One fan asked Baxley about player leadership, and his response was telling. He stressed that beyond X’s and O’s, the presence of vocal, accountable leaders in the locker room can shape the team’s resilience. The 2025 squad will rely heavily on veterans to guide younger players through the grind of the season, maintain focus during adversity, and set the standard in practice and preparation.

In wrapping up his Q&A, Baxley struck a balanced tone. He didn’t shy away from pointing out the areas where Oklahoma State must improve, but he also underscored that the program’s history under Mike Gundy has shown an ability to adapt and surprise skeptics. The Cowboys may not enter the season as Big 12 favorites, but they are far from irrelevant in the conversation.

For Oklahoma State fans, Baxley’s answers serve as both a reality check and a source of cautious optimism. The path to the top will be challenging, but if the roster’s potential can be unlocked and key leaders step forward, 2025 could still deliver a season worth remembering — even if it falls short of a championship run.